An experimental method is developed to identify a suitable model of in-elastic behaviour of an adhesive layer. Two prototype models are considered: an elastic-plastic model where the in-elasticity is considered due to permanent straining of the adhesive and an elastic-damage model where the in-elasticity is due to a reduction in elastic stiffness. Simulations show that the evaluated property is sensitive to the choice of model. In the experimental study of an engineering epoxy adhesive, the elastic-damage model fits the experiments. The study also reveals that plasticity and damage accumulated at the crack tip influences the evaluated fracture properties.